Jason Churchill of espn.com compared the 1996 Draft against the 1997 Draft. Unlike last week when he compared the 1994 and 1995 drafts and determined 1995 to be better, Jason doesn't give us his opinion on these two drafts. That means it is up to us. Tell us what do you think.
1996 Draft
No 1 Pick: Kris Benson hasn't been what any team would want out of a #1 draft pick and certainly did not produce for the Pirates. In 2000, Benson had a 3.85 ERA with 184Ks in 217.1 IP but missed all of 2001 with Tommy John surgery.
Best Pick, 1st Round: Gil Meche, #22 Seattle Mariners
Value Pick, Any Round: Roy Oswalt, 23rd round, #684 overall, Houston Astros; Travis Hafner, 31st round, #923 overall, Texas Rangers; Orlando Hudson, 33rd round, #969 overall, Toronto Blue Jays.
Notable Pick: Jimmy Rollins, 2nd round, #46 overall, Philadelphia Phillies
Worst Pick, First Round: Chad Green, #8 Milwaukee Brewers - "In eight minor league seasons, Green hit .252/.310/.389 with 166 stolen bases."
1997 Draft
No 1 Pick: Matt Anderson reached 100 on the radar a number of times over seven major league seasons for the Tigers, but ultimately his production and career was cut short by injuries.
Best Pick, 1st Round: Lance Berkman, #16 Houston Astros
Value Pick, Any Round: Tim Hudson, 6th round, #185 overall, Oakland Athletics; JC Romero, 22nd round, #633 overall, Minnesota Twins; Scot Shields, 38th round, #1,137 overall, Anaheim Angels.
Notable Pick: Chase Utley, 2nd round, Los Angeles Dodgers. Utley went to college instead of signing with the Dodgers and was drafted by the Phillies in 2000 and teamed with Rollins to form the core of the Phillies 2008 championship run.
Worst Pick, First Round: Matt Anderson, #1 Detroit Tigers: When JD Drew, Troy Glaus and Vernon Wells are available, this is a bad pick.