Baseball Rumor Mill

Updated Scouting Reports: Manny Machado, Nick Castellanos

Keith Law of espn.com recently got to see two high school shortstops who play in Florida and provide an updated scouting report on the pair.  One, Manny Machado, he calls the second best prospect in the draft - behind Bryce Harper and ahead of Jameson Taillon - and the other, Nick Castellanos, figures to be selected in the first round.

Manny Machado, Brito Miami Private HS, SS

Manny Machado is going to get the Alex Rodriguez comparison - tall, athletic, right-handed-hitting Latino shortstop from a Miami-area high school - but A-Rod Lite is more apt, since he's not preternaturally gifted as a hitter as A-Rod was. Machado can hit with strong, quick wrists, good rotation, and excellent extension through his swing.  He has a 70 (out of 80) arm and good hands at shortstop although there's some sentiment that he'll outgrow the position.  He's going to fill out significantly over the next 10 years, but he has the tools to be a plus defender at shortstop.

Manny Machado 1

Nick Castellanos, Archbishop McCarthy High School, SS

Although Castellanos lacks the defensive acumen to play shortstop professionally, his bat is still strong enough to fit at third base.  Castellanos has very strong hands and wrists, so even though he still has an 18-year-old's build, he can generate power now.  Whatever team drafts him will likely do so to play third base or even possibly a corner outfielder if necessary.  His bat projects to hit for average and power when he reaches his mid-20s.

In the comments section of Law's report, he notes that the Pirates sent a number of talent evaluators to watch Machado.  Drew Pomeranz is also a named being linked to the Pirates with the second overall pick.  Either way would leave Taillon for the Orioles with the third pick, something they'd be excited about.  The Mets have also been linked to Machado if he ever lasted to their pick, #7, but the Royals have not shown much interest picking at #4.

to read the entire article, please visit espn.com.

Olney Writes About the Pitching Trade Market

Buster Olney of espn.com gave us updates today about the various pitchers that are available and the teams going after them in his latest post.

The most obvious player is the Phillies who were looking for pitching at the start of the month when Chan Ho Park and Jaime Moyer were not pitching well.  Now that Brett Myers needs hip surgery (is this anecdotal, or are we seeing more hip surgeries recently?  Chase Utley, Mike Lowell, A-Rod and now Myers...) the Phillies border on desperate. 

Pedro Martinez doesn't seem to make much sense for Citizens Bank Ballpark and he'd like tax an already overworked bullpen with five and six inning starts. Jake Peavy and Roy Oswalt are options, but both the Padres and Astros are expected to ask for significant compensation something the Phillies might not be able to afford.  Erik Bedard is another option, but the Mariners gave us so much (Adam Jones and Chris Tillman) they may try to ask for something similar in return which might not be worth it. 

That leaves the most logical option and the one that has been frequently mentioned already: Brad Penny of the Red Sox.  Boston is a good match for the Phillies because they're rumored to be interested in shortstop Jason Donald.  The Red Sox have been rumored to be interested in Jack Wilson as well becuase of the difficulty they've had at shortstop this year, but Donald may be more appealing.

 

Reaction to Manny

There has been plenty of reaction to the news that Manny Ramirez tested positive for a performance enhancing drug yesterday:

Baseball Potpourri, 2/11: Glavine, Uggla, Cruz, Millar

Let's take a spin around the baseball rumors today:

Baseball Potpourri, 2/9: A-Rod, Kennedy, Dunn, Griffey

Alex Rodriguez admitting to steroid use is dominating the headlines today, but there's till news to report.

Teixeira Rumors, 12/19

Let's take a look at the latest Mark Teixeira rumros:

  • All the drama started today with a revealing statement from Red Sox owner John Henry: "We met with Mr. Teixeira and were very much impressed with him. After hearing about his other offers, however, it seems clear that we are not going to be a factor."
  • Teixeira's agent, Scott Boras, had a fairly standard response: "The Boston ownership was kind enough to request and travel to meet with Mark Teixeira. While it was a very positive meeting Mark was candid and advised he is in the process of making a decision and is now attempting to eliminate teams."
  • Alex Speier of WEEI gives us his take on the two statements and reviews the tepid history between Boras and the Red Sox.
  • Joel Sherman of the New York Post compares the possibility of Teixeira signing with the Nationals to Alex Rodriguez unexpectedly signing with the Rangers in 2000.  The Nationals are still waiting to hear from Teixeira regarding their contract offer.
  • Mike DiGiovanna of the Los Angeles Times spoke with Torii Hunter who spoke with Teixeira who told Hunter that the Angeles offer "blew everyone away."  DiGiovanna reports that the Red sox offer is believed to be approximately eight years and $175M while the Angels offer is believed to be in excess of eight years and $160M.
  • George King of the New York Post says that Brian Cashman tells him that the Yankees were not the team who allegedly outbid the Red Sox.

Dodgers Hope To Lure Manny With Shorter Contract

Jon Heyman of Sports Illustrated is suggesting that the Dodgers will attempt to keep Manny Ramirez in Los Angeles by going above market value on a per year basis, but offering fewer years keeping the total amount of the contract a bit lower, reducing the risk and ultimate cost to the Dodgers.  Heyman mentions that rumors about the per year amount are in the Alex Rodriguez level, $27M per year.  Ned Colletti did mention that the team had not spoken with Ramirez's agent, Scott Boras, yet.

Ramirez To Get Six Year Contract?

Yesterday, it was reported that Manny Ramirez casually suggested that he could get a six year contract in free agency.  It now appears to be not-so-casual.  Jon Heyman of Sports Illustrated reports that Scott Boras feels that Ramirez deserves a six year contract, pointing out that Barry Bonds played into his 40s and that Alex Rodriguez is signed into his 40s as well.  In a recent conversation with Boras, the New York Post's Joel Sherman writes that Boras strongly hinted at a six year deal then as well.

Should He Stay Or Should He Go: Brian Cashman

Buster Olney takes a look at reasons why general manager Brian Cashman should leave New York when his contract runs up at the end of the 2008 season or return to the team he's worked for his entire life. 

Go:

  1. Alex Rodriguez: If his production ever started to wane as the slugger continues on the wrong side of 30, he'd be virtually impossible to move because of his contract and chase of Barry Bonds home run record
  2. An exit from New York would dramatically reduce Cashman's daily stress level.  That's no secret.
  3. Hank Steinbrenner: He may not have much involvement with the actual operation of the team, but his blusterings every week or so are a mess that Cashman often ends up cleaning
  4. Derek Jeter: The fan favorite and future Hall of Famer is declining defensively at shortstop and will ultimately need to be moved to the outfield or first base.  That's not going to be a pleasant conversatoin

Stay:

  1. Cashman has lived his entire life in New York.  So has his wife.
  2. The Yankees embattled general manager has been with New York for over two decades and truly feels that the Yankees are a special part of New York that needs to be handled properly.  He's certainly been the man to do that so far.
  3. No team in baseball can provide Cashman with the money, personel and access that a general manager can want to develop a team...with the right direction.
  4. In 2005 Cashman took over the baseball operations department and rededicated the team to the amateur draft, the way the Yankees built the 96-00 dynasty.  The Yankees are still a few years away from seeing the fruits of that organizational change and Cashman may want to finish what he started.
  5. If Cashman does stay and the team is able to turn things around with a philosophical change to making the draft important again, Cashman will certainly go down as one of the most influential front office men in Yankees history, if not all of baseball as well. 

 

Subscribe to Baseball Rumor Mill

Follow us on Twitter at @BaseballRM

2010 First Round Picks

Bryce Harper
Bryce Harper
Jameson Taillon
Jameson Taillon
Manny Machado
Manny Machado
Christian Colon
Christian Colon
Drew Pomeranz
Drew Pomeranz
Barret Loux
Barret Loux
Matt Harvey
Matt Harvey
Delino DeShields Jr.
Delino DeShields Jr.
Karsten Whitson
Karsten Whitson
Michael Choice
Michael Choice
Deck McGuire
Deck McGuire
Yasmani Grandal
Yasmani Grandal
Chris Sale
Chris Sale
Dylan Covey
Dylan Covey
Jake Skole
Jake Skole
Hayden Simpson
Hayden Simpson
Josh Sale
Josh Sale
Kaleb Cowart
Kaleb Cowart
Mike Foltynewicz
Mike Foltynewicz
Kolbrin Vitek
Kolbrin Vitek
Alex Wimmers
Alex Wimmers
Kellin Deglan
Kellin Deglan
Christian Yelich
Christian Yelich
Gary Brown
Gary Brown
Zack Cox
Zack Cox
Kyle Parker
Kyle Parker
Jesse Biddle
Jesse Biddle
Zach Lee
Zach Lee
Cameron Bedrosian
Cameron Bedrosian
Chevez Clarke
Chevez Clarke
Justin O'Connor
Justin O'Connor
Cito Culver
Cito Culver