Baseball Rumor Mill

Top 20 Baseball Prospects For 2010

Recently, a number of respected baseball media outlets have released their respective lists of the top number of prospects heading into the 2010 season.  These lists include Keith Law of espn.com's Top 100, Jonathan Mayo's collection of top prospects starting with Scouting the Sally's Top 30, Oriolesprospects.com Top 20, Propects Paradise's Top 30, Camden Crazies Top 25, Dave Barr's Hot Corner Top 20, Prospect Junkie's Top 20, The Cardinal Nation's Top 40, Seth Stohs from sethspeaks.net's Top 20, and Mayo's Top 50.

Obviously this all represents opinion, but to get a better idea of the overall feel of the group Baseball Rumor Mill averaged the Top 20 rankings from all of the lists to come up with an aggregate ranking of the Top 20 prospects heading into 2010. 

The rankings were tabulated only evaluating the Top 20 of each list and a point value was assigned to each rank.  #1 = 20 points, #2 = 19 points, so on down to #20 = 1 point.  If a player was not listed in the Top 20 a NR indication was given and no points were awarded.  The rankings are based on aggregate point totals, though we also did an evaluation of point totals after dropping the highest ranking and lowest ranking.  For instance, Desmond Jennings finished fifth overall in aggregate, but would be tied for 3rd with Buster Posey after dropping each player's highest and lowest ranking.

To view the raw data, click here.

Not surprisingly, Jason Heyward and Stephen Strasburg were significantly ahead of the field at the #1 and #2 spot, respectively.  There seems to be a considerable drop in consensus after either Dustin Ackley at #12 or Madison Bumgarner at #13.  Only ten players received Top 20 votes in all ten rankings.

Without further ado, the aggregate rankings

  1. Jason Heyward, OF Atlanta
  2. Stephen Strasburg, P Washington
  3. Buster Posey, C San Francisco
  4. Brian Matsuz, P Baltimore
  5. Desmond Jennings, OF Tampa Bay
  6. Carlos Santana, C Cleveland
  7. Jesus Montero, C New York Yankees
  8. Neftali Feliz, P Texas
  9. Mike Stanton, OF Florida
  10. Pedro Alvarez, 3B Pittsburgh
  11. Justin Smoak, 1B Texas
  12. Dustin Ackley, OF Seattle
  13. Madison Bumgarner, P San Francisco
  14. Aroldis Chapman, P Cincinnati
  15. Domonic Brown, OF Philadelphia
  16. Jeremy Hellickson, P Tampa Bay
  17. Martin Perez, P Texas
  18. Alcides Escobar, SS Brewers
  19. Wade Davis, P Tampa Bay
  20. Chris Carter, 1B Oakland

Stephen Strasburg Photo

Less than a year after being the #1 draft pick, Strasburg rates as the #2 prospect in baseball

Friday's Roy Halladay Rumors

Plenty to talk about with Roy Halladay trade rumors.

More Halladay Rumors

The trading action is warming up today with the Red Sox acquiring Adam LaRoche and trading Julio Lugo for Chris Duncan, but Roy Halladay still dominated all of the headlines. Here's what's out there today.

News and Notes From Rosenthal, 11/4: Fielder, Peavy, Cubs, Holliday

Let's take a look at Ken Rosenthal's latest column:

  • The Brewers are not interested in trading Prince Fielder and hesitant to trade JJ Hardy or Alcides Escobar.
  • The Braves still seem like the favorite to land Jake Peavy but it's possible that another NL team could incorporated a third team to steal Peavy.
  • The Cubs are expected to spend most of their available payroll on pitching and that could make it difficult to sign an outfielder such as Bobby Abreu.
  • Francisco Rodriguez, Brian Fuentes, Kerry Wood and Joe Beimel are relievers that interest the Mets.
  • There is the possibility that the Cardinals could look to move either Ryan Ludwick or Rick Ankiel if Colby Rasmus is ready. 
  • David Eckstein is willing to move to second base for 2009 in order to land a starting job.
  • Rumors of the Phillies moving Shane Victorino (amongst others) for Matt Holliday are not likely.
  • The Cardinals and Nationals are not in the running for AJ Burnett.
  • Scott Olsen is likely to be available, but the Marlins probably will not shop him until the big free agent pitchers have signed.

News and Notes From Heyman, 10/6: Cain, Hardy, Ramirez, Burnett

Jon Heyman has a new article on si.com:

  • Despite rumors that the Brewers would like to retain interim manager Dale Sveum, Heyman says that Sveum's status in Milwaukee is very tenuous.
  • The Brewers denied rumors that they were trading Prince Fielder, JJ Hardy and a third player for Matt Cain.  Boy, NO ONE believes Brian Sabean when he says he's not trading Cain.  The Brewers had to deny this story, not the Giants.
  • Instead of trading Hardy to make room for Alcides Escobar, the Brewers could move him to second base, as well.
  • An unnamed GM said that the Mets will make a big run for Manny Ramirez.
  • Another GM said that the Blue Jays contract extension offer to AJ Burnett would still not be enough to keep AJ in Toronto.
  • The Mets feel that Luis Castillo, Aaron Heilman and Ryan Church would play much better outside of New York.  Does this mean they're trade bait?

Subscribe to Baseball Rumor Mill

Follow us on Twitter at @BaseballRM

2010 First Round Picks

Bryce Harper
Bryce Harper
Jameson Taillon
Jameson Taillon
Manny Machado
Manny Machado
Christian Colon
Christian Colon
Drew Pomeranz
Drew Pomeranz
Barret Loux
Barret Loux
Matt Harvey
Matt Harvey
Delino DeShields Jr.
Delino DeShields Jr.
Karsten Whitson
Karsten Whitson
Michael Choice
Michael Choice
Deck McGuire
Deck McGuire
Yasmani Grandal
Yasmani Grandal
Chris Sale
Chris Sale
Dylan Covey
Dylan Covey
Jake Skole
Jake Skole
Hayden Simpson
Hayden Simpson
Josh Sale
Josh Sale
Kaleb Cowart
Kaleb Cowart
Mike Foltynewicz
Mike Foltynewicz
Kolbrin Vitek
Kolbrin Vitek
Alex Wimmers
Alex Wimmers
Kellin Deglan
Kellin Deglan
Christian Yelich
Christian Yelich
Gary Brown
Gary Brown
Zack Cox
Zack Cox
Kyle Parker
Kyle Parker
Jesse Biddle
Jesse Biddle
Zach Lee
Zach Lee
Cameron Bedrosian
Cameron Bedrosian
Chevez Clarke
Chevez Clarke
Justin O'Connor
Justin O'Connor
Cito Culver
Cito Culver